What Glove Is Right for You?

Choosing the right baseball or softball glove can make all the difference in your performance on the field. Whether you're a beginner or a seasoned player, this guide will help you find the perfect glove for your position, age, and skill level.

Step 1: Know Your Position

The most important factor in choosing a glove is your position. Each position has specific glove designs built to help you perform your best.

Infield Gloves

Infielders need a smaller, shallower glove for quick transfers from glove to throwing hand. Look for gloves between 11" and 11.75". A shallow pocket helps you get the ball out fast for those critical double plays.

Outfield Gloves

Outfielders need a larger glove with a deeper pocket to help track down fly balls. Look for gloves between 12" and 12.75". The extra length gives you more range in the outfield.

First Base Mitts

First basemen use a mitt (no individual fingers) with a long, curved design to scoop throws from infielders. First base mitts typically range from 12" to 13". Look for a deep pocket and a wide, flexible design.

Catcher's Mitts

Catchers use a heavily padded mitt without individual fingers to handle high-velocity pitches. Catcher's mitts are measured by circumference rather than length, typically ranging from 32" to 34". Look for extra padding and a break-in style that suits your preference.

Pitcher's Gloves

Pitchers need a glove that conceals their grip on the ball. Look for a closed web design between 11.5" and 12" to hide the ball from batters.

Step 2: Choose the Right Size

Glove size is measured in inches from the top of the index finger down to the center of the heel. Here's a quick size guide by age:

Ages 3–5: 9" – 9.5"
Ages 6–8: 9.5" – 10.5"
Ages 9–12: 10.5" – 11.5"
Ages 13–15: 11" – 12"
Ages 16+/Adult: 11.25" – 12.75"

Step 3: Select Your Web Style

The web is the leather piece connecting the thumb and index finger. Different web styles suit different positions:

Closed Web: Great for pitchers who want to hide their grip.
Open/Basket Web: Popular with outfielders for visibility on fly balls.
H-Web / Modified Trap: Versatile option for infielders and third basemen.
Two-Piece Closed: Offers flexibility and is popular with middle infielders.

Step 4: Pick Your Material

Glove leather affects durability, break-in time, and feel:

Full-Grain Leather: Durable and long-lasting, but requires a longer break-in period. Best for serious players.
Kip Leather: Lightweight and soft, breaks in faster. Popular with elite players.
Steerhide: Tough and durable, great for players who want a glove that lasts.
Synthetic: Lightweight and game-ready right out of the box. Great for youth players and beginners.

Step 5: Break In Your Glove

A new glove needs to be broken in before it's game-ready. Here are a few tips:

Apply a small amount of glove conditioner or oil to soften the leather.
Place a ball in the pocket and wrap the glove with rubber bands or a glove wrap overnight.
Play catch as much as possible — there's no better way to break in a glove!
Avoid using a microwave or oven, as heat can damage the leather.

Still Not Sure? We're Here to Help!

Our team at The Glove Locker knows gloves inside and out. If you have questions about sizing, position fit, or recommendations for your budget, don't hesitate to contact us — we'd love to help you find your perfect glove.